Login
       

File a Claim

We pride ourselves on our customer service and our preference is for you to contact us to
report a claim.  If you need to report a claim immediately during an after hours/ holiday or
weekend, you may use the following information to contact your insurance company.

Emergency contacts:  Matt Banazek cell phone (607) 345-7369
Lee Benson cell phone (607) 345-3950

CCIC
Central Co-operative Insurance Company
http://www.centralco-op.com
Claims Office: 1-315-635-7606
Claims Manager x33 / Claims Customer Service x26
Claims Fax: 1-315-638-2002

Preferred Mutual
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
http://www.preferredmutual.com/
Claims Phone Number:  1-800-333-7642 option #4
Auto Glass/Windshield Number:  1-800-333-7642 option #8
Online Claim
Countryway Insurance
Countryway Insurance Company  http://www.countryway.com
Claims Phone Number:
M-F: 8:00AM-4:30PM EST: 1-800-828-6862
After Hours Claim Center: 1-888-223-3649:
Online Claim
Erie
Erie Insurance Group
http://www.erieinsurance.com
Whenever possible, please report claim to
Benson Davis Insurance Agency
Claims Office (24/7):  1-800-367-3743
Auto Glass Claim:  1-800-552-3743
Online Claim

National Grange Mutual
Main Street America Assurance
Old Dominion Insurance Co.
http://www.msagroup.com
Whenever possible, please report claim to
Benson Davis Insurance Agency
Claims Office (24/7):  1-877-425-2467
Online Claim

Dryden Mutual Insurance Co   http://www.drydenmutual.com
Whenever possible, please report claim to
Benson Davis Insurance Agency
Claims Office (Office Hours):  1-800-782-0154
(After Hours) 1-800-556-5802 or 1-607-428-0176
Ontario
Ontario Insurance Company
http://www.ontarioinsco.com
Please report claim to
Benson Davis Insurance Agency

Progressive
Progressive Insurance Co.
http://www.progressiveagent.com

Claims Office (24/7):  1-800-Progressive
Online Claim

Chautauqua Patrons Insurance Company    www.chautauquapatrons.com
Whenever possible, please report claim to
Benson Davis Insurance Agency
Claims Office: 1-800-896-4720
Online Claim

National General Insurance Co.
  http://www.nationalgeneral.com/claims-center/default.asp
Claims Office: 1-800-325-1088
Online Claim
   
       

All companies
PIA 5325 State Route 281, Homer, NY 13077
(607) 749-3164 F:(607) 749-9974 
© 2009-15 Benson Davis Insurance
Site by: GNC