Preferred     Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

Since 1896, our employees have dedicated themselves to building a company whose strength and vision would provide individuals, families and businesses the security necessary to protect their assets and grow their enterprises.

As a company owned by its policyholders, Preferred Mutual’s Mission is to provide the best value in all of our insurance products and services. Our strategy to meet this commitment is to align our Mission, Vision and Values with the needs of our policyholders, agents and employees in a way that differentiates Preferred Mutual from all the others!

Make a Payment


All companies
PIA 5325 State Route 281, Homer, NY 13077
(607) 749-3164 F:(607) 749-9974 
© 2009-15 Benson Davis Insurance
Site by: GNC